Artist’s impression of a black hole surrounded by a cloud of ultralight bosons. Image credit: Carl Knox / OzGrav, Swinburne University of Technology.
Exceptionally strong gravitational-wave signals have allowed researchers to place substantially stronger constraints on hypothetical ultralight particles, demonstrating the growing power of black holes as laboratories for fundamental physics. An international team of scientists from the LIGO, Virgo, and KAGRA collaborations, including researchers from the ARC Centre of Excellence for Gravitational Wave Discovery (OzGrav), have used […]
Exceptionally strong gravitational-wave signals have allowed researchers to place substantially stronger constraints on hypothetical ultralight particles, demonstrating the growing power of black holes as laboratories for fundamental physics.
An international team of scientists from the LIGO, Virgo, and KAGRA collaborations, including researchers from the ARC Centre of Excellence for Gravitational Wave Discovery (OzGrav), have used some of the loudest black hole merger signals observed to search for evidence of hypothetical ultralight particles that could help answer unresolved questions in particle physics and cosmology, including the nature of dark matter.
Artist’s animation of a black hole surrounded by a hypothetical cloud of ultralight bosons, emitting gravitational waves.
Credit: Carl Knox / OzGrav, Swinburne University of Technology.
The study combines two complementary ways of hunting for ultralight bosons: a direct search for long-transient gravitational waves from clouds of particles surrounding newly formed black holes, and an indirect analysis based on the spins of black holes before they merge.
OzGrav PhD student Aswathi Pampurayath Subhash from the Australian National University (ANU) said the two approaches allow researchers to look for the same underlying physics in different ways.
“We used two complementary methods to hunt for these ultralight bosonic particles: a directed search for gravitational waves from boson clouds, and constraints from black hole spin measurements.”
For the direct search, the team targeted the newly formed black holes left behind by two exceptionally loud mergers, GW250114 and GW250207. These remnants provide particularly valuable targets because researchers observed their formation and can use the merger signals to determine important properties, including their mass and spin.
The team was able to disfavour a range of vector boson masses with greater than 90 per cent confidence, a significant improvement on the first search of this kind in an earlier LVK study, which included contributions from ANU Postdoc and OzGrav researcher Dr Dana Jones, and achieved around 30 to 40 per cent confidence for excluding some of the vector boson masses.
Dr Ling (Lilli) Sun from ANU and Chief Investigator at OzGrav said the improvement shows how quickly gravitational-wave astronomy is developing into a tool for testing fundamental physics.
“This is the first strong constraint we get from searches for these clouds targeting newly born black holes in mergers,” she said.
“The first time we ran this search, we were starting to reach the sensitivity where we could say something about it, but the confidence level was not high. This time, with these very loud events, we can get to more than 90 per cent confidence.”
“It’s really showing that higher signal-to-noise ratio events and better detector sensitivity give us the capability to test fundamental physics,” Sun said.
An invisible cloud around a black hole
Ultralight bosons are hypothetical particles predicted by many theories that extend the Standard Model of particle physics. They would be extraordinarily light, many orders of magnitude lighter than known particles, and are considered possible candidates for dark matter.
Unlike ordinary particles, some hypothetical ultralight bosons may interact extremely weakly with conventional matter, making them exceptionally difficult to detect in laboratory experiments. However, they would still interact through gravity, meaning rapidly rotating black holes could provide a way to investigate their existence.
Through a process known as black hole superradiance, a rapidly rotating black hole can transfer part of its mass and rotational energy to the bosonic field, allowing a huge, invisible cloud of particles to form around it.
As the cloud grows, it extracts angular momentum from the black hole, causing the black hole to spin down. The cloud can then emit long-lasting gravitational waves that are nearly monochromatic, meaning they remain close to a single frequency.
For newly formed black holes, those gravitational waves could persist for hours to months after the original merger, giving scientists another signal to search for after the familiar gravitational-wave “chirp” from the collision itself has passed.
Subhash said the merger itself could mark the beginning of a new opportunity to investigate fundamental physics.
“The merger is not necessarily the end of the story. Even after we detect the initial collision, we can continue searching for gravitational waves from a possible boson cloud around the newly formed black hole, opening up another way to test fundamental physics.”
Although no boson-cloud signal was detected, the non-detection allowed the researchers to place strong constraints on the particle masses that could have produced an observable signal.
Two different ways of asking the same question
In addition to looking for a boson cloud around a newly formed black hole after a merger, they examined the spins of older black holes before they merged.
If ultralight bosons with particular masses existed, superradiance should have extracted rotational energy from those black holes over time and slowed them down. Finding black holes that are still spinning rapidly can therefore help researchers identify which boson masses are unlikely to exist.
The two approaches also have different sensitivities: measurements of black hole spins can help constrain both scalar and vector bosons, while the direct gravitational-wave search in this study focuses on vector bosons, whose predicted signals offer a better prospect of detection with current instruments.
Sun said the advantage of the two approaches is that they look at completely different phenomena and come with different assumptions and uncertainties.
“One is looking at those old black holes and asking: are they still spinning fast, or have they already spun down?” she said.
“The other search is looking for a new cloud that can form around the newly born black hole. They are two different stories, but in one paper.”
Using two independent methods also provides an important cross-check.
“Each method has its own limitation or uncertainty,” Sun said. “But if you use two completely different methods, looking at completely different phenomena, and they give you the same answer saying these particles are unlikely to exist in this region, that’s more convincing.”
Black holes as laboratories for new physics
The absence of a signal does not mean ultralight bosons do not exist. Instead, the results make it increasingly unlikely that these particles exist within particular mass ranges where they should have produced observable effects.
By combining a direct search for gravitational waves from vector boson clouds with independent constraints from rapidly spinning black holes, the study places some of the strongest gravitational-wave constraints to date on ultralight vector bosons within the specific particle mass range investigated, around 10^-13 electronvolts.
As detector sensitivity continues to improve and the number of observed black hole mergers grows, researchers will be able to probe an increasingly large fraction of the possible ultralight-boson parameter space.
Future observations could eventually reveal a direct signature of new particles or continue narrowing the range of theories in which they could exist.
This research demonstrates how black holes and gravitational waves can be used as powerful laboratories for particle physics, testing ideas that are difficult or impossible to investigate in experiments on Earth.
Read the published paper: Physical Review D
Watch the explainer video
