A Decade’s Worth Of Gravitational Wave Data Reveals New Black Hole Behaviour

In 1916, Albert Einstein published the paper that predicted gravitational waves – ripples in the fabric of space-time resulting from the most violent phenomena in our distant universe, such as supernovae explosions or colliding black holes.

It took a century for Einstein’s theory to be proven when, in September 2015, the newly commissioned Advanced Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory (LIGO) detectors observed gravitational waves that resulted from merging black holes approximately 1.3 billion light-years away. This watershed achievement earned three of LIGO’s founding members the 2017 Nobel Prize in Physics.

Today, more than 80 Australian researchers, amongst over 2000 scientists globally, have published data on the whole catalogue of gravitational-wave observations accumulated since September 2015. In total, 218 events have been recorded including three types of binary mergers: binary neutron star; neutron star–black hole; and binary black hole mergers.

Black holes have a gravitational pull so strong that nothing, not even light, can escape it. This makes them difficult to detect with conventional telescopes. They are characterised by their masses, measured in units equivalent to the mass of our Sun, and their spins.

According to lead Australian author, Christian Adamcewicz, from Monash University and the ARC Centre of Excellence for Gravitational Wave Discovery (OzGrav), many aspects of these black holes and the stars that form them remain a mystery.

“By observing the rapidly growing population of compact binary mergers through gravitational waves, thanks to our increasingly sensitive detectors, we’re uncovering vital clues about the lives and deaths of stars,” says Dr Ling Sun from the Australian National University and OzGrav. “Taking the 161 of the 218 mergers seen in the last decade, we’ve been able to decipher aspects of their behaviour from their masses,” Adamcewicz added.

“We found that most black holes have masses less than about 40 times that of our Sun. For a while, we’ve had this hypothesis that heavy black hole progenitors – the stars we would normally expect to turn into black holes heavier than 40 Suns – create supernovae so explosive that any evidence of them is annihilated. We’d never seen clear evidence for that previously, but this newly discovered drop off in our observations matches that prediction really well.”

He adds that “it’s not possible to test stuff on this scale in the lab, so, while we wait to collect the data we need, we rely on extrapolating and piecing together our knowledge from other areas. When you’re talking about the most extreme events in the Universe, these assumptions often break down. In this case, what we thought we would see with black holes in that mass range turned out to be accurate.” Sun shares a similar sentiment; “these cosmic collisions serve as natural laboratories, helping us piece together how black holes and neutron stars form, evolve, and interact across the Universe.”

Gravity Tests with the Double Pulsar Honoured

2025 Frontiers of Science Award for the international Double Pulsar research team

The research paper “Strong-Field Gravity Tests with the Double Pulsar” led by OzGrav Partner Investigator Michael Kramer (Max Planck Institute for Radio Astronomy, MPIfR) and including OzGrav Chief Investigator Adam Deller (Swinburne University) along with an international research team was published in the journal “Physical Review X” (Kramer et al. 041050, December 13, 2021). Their work received the Frontiers of Science award within the category “Astrophysics and Cosmology – theory” from the International Congress for Basic Science (ICBS). The award ceremony took place at the China National Conference Center (CNCC) – on July 13, 2025.

More than 100 years after Albert Einstein presented his theory of gravity, scientists around the world continue to search for tiny deviations from its predictions that would point the way to a new theoretical understanding of the laws that govern the Universe. Binary radio pulsars – rapidly spinning neutron stars whose beamed radio emission can be observed as precise clock ticks from the Earth – are ideal laboratories for searching for such deviations. The “double pulsar” system, which was the subject of the paper honoured by the ICBS, is the best such system currently known for making these ultra precise tests. “We studied a system of very compact stars to test gravity theories in the presence of very strong gravitational fields,”, states the research team’s leader, Michael Kramer from the Max Planck Institute for Radio Astronomy (MPIfR) in Bonn, Germany. “To our delight we were able to test a cornerstone of Einstein’s theory, the energy carried by gravitational waves, with a precision that is 25 times better than with the Nobel-Prize winning Hulse-Taylor pulsar.”

Apart from the loss of orbital energy through gravitational waves, other relativistic effects such as the periastron advance of the system (which has precessed around a full turn since its discovery over 20 years ago!), relativistic time dilation, and spacetime curvature have all been precisely measured in the double pulsar system, with every result agreeing with Einstein’s predictions to within the measurement uncertainty.

Such tests are only possible through careful calibration of the observed pulsar “clock ticks” for other effects that are unrelated to general relativity. As one example, the motion of the pulsar relative to the Earth, and its acceleration in the gravitational field of the Milky Way, contribute to the observed change in its orbital period. Fortunately, these effects can be calculated and corrected if the distance to the double pulsar and its motion on the sky are known. Prof Adam Deller led additional observations that measured tiny shifts in the position of the double pulsar system on the sky to provide these corrections. “By measuring how the double pulsar’s position shifted over the course of a year as the Earth orbits the Sun, we can infer how distant it is” said Prof. Deller. “But the position shifts are tiny – like seeing an ant crawl around a button from 5,000 km away!”

This combination of diverse effects produced by a system of two strongly self-gravitating bodies with extreme spacetime curvature makes the Double Pulsar a unique testbed — not only for general relativity but also for various competing theories, some of which have been significantly constrained or even excluded by this experiment.

“We are very pleased with the award honouring our work with the Double Pulsar which is the result of a collaboration with great colleagues, who together allowed us to combine our precision experiments with a rigorous theoretical understanding,” concludes Michael Kramer.

Marta Burgay (left) and Michael Kramer (right) receiving the 2025 Frontiers of Science Award on behalf of all the authors of the Kramer et al. (2021) Double Pulsar paper. Credit: ICBS
Marta Burgay (left) and Michael Kramer (right) receiving the 2025 Frontiers of Science Award on behalf of all the authors of the Kramer et al. (2021) Double Pulsar paper. Credit: ICBS

 

Original Paper

Kramer et al. Strong-Field Gravity Tests with the Double Pulsar, 2021, Physical Review X, December 13, 2021 (DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevX.11.041050).

https://journals.aps.org/prx/accepted/a7077K4fR4216c02853742f061ca5a31085788a3e

Further Information/Links:

Fundamental Physics in Radio Astronomy. Research Department at MPIfR

https://www.mpifr-bonn.mpg.de/research/fundamental

The 2025 Frontiers of Science Award

https://www.icbs.cn/site/pages/index/index?pageId=1fe7d1cf-c69c-47bd-a2fa-3d5731ca2610