How Continuous Gravitational Waves from Neutron Stars Could Reveal New Physics

Neutron stars are extremely dense objects, second only to black holes. A teaspoon of neutron star matter weighs as much as Mt. Everest. Under such high densities, neutron stars possess exotic physics that cannot be reproduced on Earth.

We have been studying a subgroup of neutron stars, namely pulsars, that release their energies mainly through electromagnetic radiation. But these stars are only a fraction of the total neutron star population in the Milky Way Galaxy. We are missing out on other types of neutron stars that may not produce much electromagnetic radiation.

As a neutron star rotates, any mountains on its surface – even if they are just a few millimetres tall – will create ripples in the four-dimensional fabric of space- time. Such ripples are known as continuous gravitational waves, or continuous waves for short. Compared to the gravitational waves that have been detected, continuous waves are fainter but constant – similar to the humming of a fridge, as opposed to a loud bang.

Observing neutron stars through continuous waves provides us with information that is complementary to what can be learnt from pulsars, so that we can paint a more complete picture of the unknown physics that lies within. However, continuous waves from neutron stars are still undetected. To know whether they are detectable, and what we can learn from them, we need to perform simulations to see if our current and future gravitational wave detectors can detect continuous waves.

In this study, we looked at the capabilities of two detectors: LIGO, the first to detect gravitational waves in 2015; and the Einstein Telescope, a next- generation detector that is expected to be constructed in the 2030s. The first step to detecting continuous waves is to make sure that we are looking at the right place. The current catalogue of neutron stars contains only pulsars that may not emit any continuous waves. To get a full picture of the neutron star population in the Galaxy, we also need neutron stars that emit continuous waves. We simulated the entire neutron star population in the Galaxy, which includes continuous wave-emitting neutron stars. These stars have different energies and release different amounts of electromagnetic and continuous waves.

From this population of neutron stars, we then estimated the continuous waves produced by these stars, and how the two detectors respond to them. Using a technique called Bayesian inference, we performed searches on the faint “hums” amidst all the additional noise from the detectors. Being a next- generation detector, the Einstein Telescope is larger and more sensitive than LIGO, so the weak continuous wave signals can be more easily identified – just like how you can hear fainter sounds when you are in a quieter room.

The factor that determines the amount of continuous waves generated, known as the ellipticity, could be measured by the Einstein Telescope with an error of between 5 and 50% with 5 years of observation. This property of the neutron star cannot be determined by other methods. The limiting factor, we found, is the preciseness of our measurement of a quantity called the braking index. This number determines the fraction of a neutron star’s energy that is released as continuous waves. The ability to measure this number directly affects our measurement of ellipticity.

Our study demonstrated that future detectors, such as the Einstein Telescope, can detect continuous waves. Neutron star properties such as ellipticity, which previously could not be determined, can then be measured through the detected continuous waves. Our work provides a new way to probe the physics of neutron stars, and additional motivation to construct the next generation of gravitational wave detectors.

Reference: “Population Synthesis and Parameter Estimation of Neutron Stars with Continuous Gravitational Waves and Third-Generation Detectors”

Yuhan Hua, Karl Wette, Susan M. Scott, Matthew D. Pitkin.

Published on arXiv.

Australian researchers give weight to NASA neutron star study

Artist's impression showing a companion white-dwarf star orbiting a pulsar. The dense companion warps the fabric of spacetime, compressing it, and delaying the pulses coming from the pulsar. Credit: Carl Knox / OzGrav
Artist’s impression showing a companion white-dwarf star orbiting a pulsar. The dense companion warps the fabric of spacetime, compressing it, and delaying the pulses coming from the pulsar. Credit: Carl Knox / OzGrav

 

A neutron star close to Earth is spinning as fast as a blender. Known as a millisecond pulsar, it is rotating at 174 times per second but much of its characteristics have remained a mystery. Now, thanks to almost 30 years of observations from Murriyang, CSIRO’s Parkes radio telescope, we know its mass. And that’s the key to knowing so much more.  

In a series of three papers accepted for publication in Astrophysical Journal Letters, a global group of scientists describe how Murriyang together with NICER (Neutron Star Interior Composition ExploreR), NASA’s X-ray telescope on the International Space Station, have accurately measured the mass and radius of this nearby neutron star. 

According to the Australian lead researcher on the project Dr Daniel Reardon, from the ARC Centre of Excellence for Gravitational Wave Discovery (OzGrav) and Swinburne University of Technology, a neutron star is made of extreme matter on the brink of becoming a black hole.  

“Being able to measure its mass and radius tells us how squeezable neutron stars are and how matter behaves inside their dense core, which is denser than the nucleus of an atom,” he said.  

Particle accelerators, such as the Large Hadron Collider, are also used to study matter at its extremes, but these experiments fail to predict the behaviour of the unique matter in the cores of neutron stars. This means neutron stars are some of the best laboratories for physics. Measuring their masses and sizes is a way to get new insights into fundamental nuclear physics.  

NICER is on a mission to study neutron star interiors by detecting and mapping X-ray emission from million-degree hot spots on the surface of the star. Dr Reardon, the OzGrav team, and other researchers using radio data from Murriyang, owned and operated by CSIRO, Australia’s national science agency, provided the mass of the pulsar, a key part of the NICER mission to measure the radius. 

Dr Reardon has been observing this neutron star since he was a student ten years ago. 

“There were researchers studying the same pulsar with Murriyang for twenty years before me. It’s important that we have long-term data on the star to get accurate information,” he said.  

This is part of the Parkes Pulsar Timing Array (PPTA) collaboration to monitor a set of pulsars over long timescales. 

Dr Andrew Zic (CSIRO), Primary Investigator of the PPTA project, says the collaboration’s precise measurements of pulsars with Murriyang has produced highly valuable datasets for many projects. 

“This has been made possible by regular upgrades to Murriyang, which has meant that our PPTA data have consistently been of world-leading quality, as seen in this work,” Dr Zic said. 

By compiling and analysing this large data set, researchers are getting closer to detecting gravitational waves with pulsars. Dr Reardon and the team used this data to support the NICER mission in a novel way.  

“At CSIRO’s Parkes Observatory we have been tracking – for decades – tiny (microsecond) delays in the arrival times of pulses sent out the neutron star, caused by space compressing due to the mass of its white-dwarf companion star,” Dr Reardon said.  

Space is stretched and squashed by the mass of objects, which is described in Einstein’s theory of gravity. The microsecond delays are predicted by the theory and the detailed information collected over many years allowed the team to accurately calculate the mass of both the dwarf star and the pulsar.  

With the mass confirmed, the NICER team could then calculate the radius of the pulsar from their data. This helps build a picture of the matter making up a neutron star.  

Understanding the matter will allow scientists to better predict the gravitational wave signatures created when neutron stars collide and collapse into black holes. Neutron star collisions release a burst of gravitational waves in an enormous explosion called a kilonova, which can be seen by many telescopes, including Xray telescopes and radio ones.  

According to OzGrav’s Dr Anais Möller from Swinburne University of Technology, an expert in searching for these collisions, measuring the mass and radius of pulsars tells us how neutron stars might get ripped apart and what we can expect to see in the resulting kilonova. 

Dr Reardon says because this pulsar has a mass similar to a typical neutron star, measuring its mass and radius is crucial for understanding the behaviour of matter at extreme densities.  

“This research advances our fundamental understanding of how the Universe operates.” 

SLOW-SPINNING RADIO NEUTRON STAR BREAKS ALL THE RULES

Australian scientists from the University of Sydney and Australia’s national science agency, CSIRO, have detected what is likely a neutron star spinning slower than any other ever measured.

No other radio-emitting neutron star, out of the more than 3000 discovered so far, has been discovered rotating so slowly. The results are published today in Nature Astronomy.

Lead author Dr Manisha Caleb from the University of Sydney Institute for Astronomy said: “It is highly unusual to discover a neutron star candidate emitting radio pulsations in this way. The fact that the signal is repeating at such a leisurely pace is extraordinary.”

This unusual neutron star is emitting radio light at a rate that is too slow to fit with current descriptions of radio neutron star behaviour. This provides new insights into the complex life cycles of stellar objects.

At the end of their life, large stars about 10 times the mass of the Sun use up all their fuel and explode in a spectacular blast we call a supernova. What remains is a stellar remnant so dense that 1.4 times the mass of our Sun is packed into a ball just 20 kilometres across.

Matter is so dense that negatively charged electrons are crushed into positively charged protons and what’s left is an object made up of trillions of neutrally charged particles. A neutron star is born.

Given the extreme physics with which these stars collapse, neutron stars typically rotate mind-bendingly fast, taking just seconds or even fractions of a second to fully spin on their axis.

Now, astronomers at the University of Sydney and CSIRO have discovered a compact object repeating its signal with a comparatively leisurely period just shy of one hour.

The discovery was made using CSIRO’s ASKAP radio telescope on Wajarri Yamaji Country in Western Australia.

The ASKAP radio telescope can see a large part of the sky at once, which means it can capture things researchers aren’t even looking for. CSIRO scientist Dr Emil Lenc, co-lead author on the paper, said they wouldn’t have found this strange object if it wasn’t for ASKAP’s unique design.

“We were simultaneously monitoring a source of gamma rays and seeking a fast radio burst when I spotted this object slowly flashing in the data. Three very different things in one field-of-view,” he said.

“ASKAP is one of the best telescopes in the world for this sort of research, as it is constantly scanning so much of the sky, allowing us to detect any anomalies.”

The origin of such a long period signal remains a profound mystery, although two types of stars are prime suspects – white dwarfs and neutron stars.

“What is intriguing is how this object displays three distinct emission states, each with properties entirely dissimilar from the others. The MeerKAT radio telescope in South Africa played a crucial role in distinguishing between these states. If the signals didn’t arise from the same point in the sky, we would not have believed it to be the same object producing these different signals,” Dr Caleb said.

While an isolated white dwarf with an extraordinarily strong magnetic field could produce the observed signal, it is surprising that nearby highly-magnetic isolated white dwarfs have never been discovered. Conversely, a neutron star with extreme magnetic fields can quite elegantly explain the observed emissions.

While a slow-spinning neutron star is the likely explanation, researchers said they cannot rule out that the object is part of a binary system with a neutron star or another white dwarf.

More research will be required to confirm whether the object is a neutron star or white dwarf. Either way, it will provide valuable insights into the physics of these extreme objects.

“It might even prompt us to reconsider our decades-old understanding of neutron stars or white dwarfs; how they emit radio waves and what their populations are like in our Milky Way galaxy,” Dr Caleb said.

Professor Tara Murphy, leading radio astronomer and head of the School of Physics at the University of Sydney, said: “Until the advent of our new telescopes, the dynamic radio sky has been relatively unexplored. Now we’re able to look deeply, and often, we are seeing all kinds of unusual phenomena. These events give us insights into how physics works in extreme environments.”